IRS Criminal Investigation

When the IRS stops asking what you owe and starts asking whether you meant it.

We are not currently accepting criminal tax defense cases. If you are under criminal investigation, we will refer you to criminal tax defense counsel.

This page explains what to do in the meantime, and what to tell the agent.

Has an IRS special agent contacted you? You do not have to answer questions on the spot.

Be polite, take the agent's card, and say your lawyer will be in touch. Then call a criminal tax lawyer before you say anything else.

Signs a case has turned criminal

  • •A special agent contacts you. Special agents work for IRS Criminal Investigation, not the audit or collection side. At a first interview they identify themselves as special agents and show their credentials (IRM 9.4.5.8.3.1.1).
  • •Your auditor or revenue officer suddenly goes quiet. When an examiner finds firm indications of fraud, the manual tells them to suspend the case without telling you why (IRM 25.1.3).
  • •You ask and get no answer. Examiners may decline to answer questions about criminal potential, but the same section says they may not deceive you when you ask directly.

Some audits carry criminal risk from the start. See the eggshell audit section of our IRS audit page.

Why you should not talk to the agent alone

A special agent's job is to gather evidence. Anything you say can be used in a criminal case, and a statement that turns out to be inaccurate can become its own problem.

Special agents must advise the subject of an investigation of their constitutional rights at the start of an interview (IRM 9.4.5.8.3.1). You are allowed to use them.

Let a lawyer find out what the investigation is about before anyone answers questions.

Why a CPA or EA can't protect this conversation

CPAs and enrolled agents have a limited confidentiality privilege for tax advice. By statute it applies only in noncriminal tax matters before the IRS and noncriminal tax cases in federal court (26 U.S.C. § 7525(a)(2)).

Once a case is criminal, what you told your accountant can be reached. Attorney-client privilege is not limited to noncriminal matters, which is why the first call should go to a criminal tax lawyer.

Tax avoidance vs. tax evasion and tax fraud

Avoidance is using the law to lower your tax, such as taking deductions and credits you qualify for. Evasion and tax fraud are willful attempts to cheat.

The key word in the criminal statutes is "willfully." An honest mistake is a civil matter, even an expensive one.

Tax evasion

A willful attempt to evade or defeat a tax, or the payment of a tax. A felony with up to 5 years in prison, plus fines.

26 U.S.C. § 7201

Filing a false return

Willfully signing a return under penalties of perjury that you don't believe is true on every material point. A felony with up to 3 years in prison, plus fines.

26 U.S.C. § 7206(1)

Willful failure to file or pay

Willfully failing to file a required return or pay a tax on time. A misdemeanor with up to 1 year in prison per count, plus fines.

26 U.S.C. § 7203

For these three crimes, the government generally has 6 years to bring charges (26 U.S.C. § 6531). For more, read tax evasion and how it differs from tax avoidance.

Voluntary disclosure: coming forward first

The IRS Voluntary Disclosure Practice is for people who willfully broke the tax law and have criminal exposure. It can help them become compliant and potentially avoid prosecution, but it does not guarantee immunity (IRM 9.5.11.9).

The disclosure must be truthful, complete and timely. Timely generally means before the IRS has started, or told you it plans to start, an examination or investigation, received information about you from a third party, or obtained it through an enforcement action like a summons or search warrant.

It starts with a preclearance request on Form 14457. It also requires filing all the missing returns and arranging to pay the tax, interest and penalties.

It is not available for income from illegal sources.

Because a disclosure admits willful conduct, talk to criminal tax counsel before submitting anything. We can refer you.

If your mistakes were not willful, this program is not the right tool. Filing late or amended returns is usually the answer; see our unfiled tax returns page.

How we can help

We are not currently accepting criminal defense cases; our work is civil IRS problems. If you call us about a criminal investigation, we will refer you to criminal tax defense counsel.

Many people who fear a criminal case actually have a civil one. If yours is an audit, years of unfiled returns or a tax debt, see our IRS audit and unfiled tax returns pages.

For more background, read our post on when civil becomes criminal.

Common questions

How do I know if the IRS is investigating me criminally?

The clearest sign is contact from a special agent of IRS Criminal Investigation. Another warning sign is an auditor or revenue officer who suddenly stops working your case without explanation. When an examiner finds firm indications of fraud, the Internal Revenue Manual tells them to suspend the case without telling you why (IRM 25.1.3).

Should I talk to an IRS special agent?

Not before you talk to a lawyer. Special agents must advise the subject of an investigation of their constitutional rights at the start of the interview (IRM 9.4.5.8.3.1). You can politely decline to answer and say your lawyer will contact them.

Is my accountant's advice privileged in a criminal tax case?

No. The confidentiality privilege for CPAs and enrolled agents applies only in noncriminal tax matters before the IRS and noncriminal tax cases in federal court (26 U.S.C. § 7525(a)(2)). Attorney-client privilege is not limited that way.

What is the difference between tax avoidance and tax evasion?

Tax avoidance is lowering your tax by legal means, such as deductions and credits the law allows. Tax evasion is a willful attempt to evade or defeat a tax or its payment, a felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison (26 U.S.C. § 7201).

Can I come forward before the IRS finds me?

Possibly, if you act before the IRS does. The IRS Voluntary Disclosure Practice is for people with criminal exposure from willful noncompliance, and it does not guarantee immunity (IRM 9.5.11.9). The disclosure must be truthful, complete and timely, which generally means before the IRS has started or announced an examination or investigation, or received information about you.

Does your firm handle criminal tax cases?

Not at this time. We are not currently accepting criminal tax defense cases, and we will refer you to criminal tax defense counsel. If your problem turns out to be civil, such as an audit, unfiled returns or back taxes, that is the work we do.

Not sure if it's civil or criminal?

Call tax attorney Darrin T. Mish. If it's a civil IRS problem, we can help. If it's criminal, we will refer you to criminal tax counsel.