How to Choose an IRS Tax Attorney: What to Check Before You Hire

Darrin T. Mish

Tax Attorney • 32+ Years Experience

People search for the “best IRS tax attorney” every day. No list can answer that for you, and any lawyer who claims to be the best is telling you about their judgment, not their results.

What you can do is check a short list of facts, ask the right questions, and watch for the warning signs. Here is how.

Start With Who Can Represent You

You don’t have to hire a lawyer to deal with the IRS. Attorneys, certified public accountants and enrolled agents all have unlimited representation rights, so any of them can handle audits, payment and collection issues, and appeals.

A tax attorney makes the most sense when:

Conversations with an attorney are also protected by the attorney-client privilege. For straightforward return preparation or a simple payment plan, a CPA or enrolled agent is often the better value.

Check the Basics Yourself

These take a few minutes and cost nothing.

  • Bar status and discipline. Look the lawyer up in The Florida Bar’s member directory, or your own state bar’s, to confirm the license is active and see any public discipline.
  • Board certification. The Florida Bar has run a board certification program since 1982. If a lawyer says they’re board certified, ask in what area and by whom; the Bar lets you search for board certified lawyers.
  • Tax Court admission. Ask whether the lawyer is admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court. Attorneys are admitted on a certificate of good standing, and non-attorneys must pass the court’s written exam (Tax Court Rule 200).
  • Who does the work. Ask whether the lawyer you meet will handle your case or hand it to someone else, and who you’ll talk to when you call.

Ask About Cases Like Yours

Tax problems aren’t all the same. A lawyer who mostly does estate planning may not be the right fit for a wage garnishment.

Ask how often the lawyer handles your kind of problem: a levy, an Offer in Compromise, unfiled returns, a lien that’s blocking a sale. Ask what the realistic options are for someone with your income and assets, and what could go wrong.

Be wary of a quick answer about outcomes. Results depend on your finances and your filing history, so an honest lawyer will tell you what’s possible, not promise what will happen.

Understand How You’ll Be Charged

Ask how the fee works before you sign. Most tax resolution work is billed one of three ways:

  • A flat fee for a defined job, such as preparing unfiled returns or requesting penalty abatement
  • An hourly rate, common when the time needed is hard to predict
  • A retainer, an advance the lawyer bills against as the work is done

Get the agreement in writing, including what it covers and what it doesn’t. If the IRS work leads to Appeals or Tax Court, ask whether that’s included.

Warning Signs to Walk Away From

  • A promise to wipe out your debt, or a guaranteed result. Nobody controls what the IRS or a court will do.
  • A claim of special connections or influence with the IRS. That isn’t how it works, and a lawyer who suggests it is telling you something about their ethics.
  • Pressure to sign or pay today before anyone has looked at your transcripts and finances
  • No written fee agreement, or vague answers about who does the work
  • A pitch for a “program” before anyone asks about your income, assets and filing history

What to Bring to the First Consultation

The more you bring, the more useful the first conversation is.

  • Every IRS notice and letter you’ve received, even the ones you didn’t open
  • Your last three to five years of returns, or a list of the years you didn’t file
  • Any levy, garnishment or lien notices
  • A rough picture of your monthly income, expenses and major assets

A good consultation ends with you understanding your options, the likely next steps, and what the work will cost. If the lawyer isn’t the right fit, they should say so and point you somewhere better.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire

  • How many cases like mine do you handle in a typical year?
  • What options do you see for me, and what are the risks of each?
  • Will you be handling my case personally?
  • How long do cases like mine usually take, and what happens first?
  • How is the fee calculated, and what isn’t included?

The right IRS tax attorney is the one who tells you the truth about your options, puts the fee in writing, and does the work they said they would. Check the license, ask hard questions, and walk away from anyone selling certainty.

Tax attorney Darrin Mish has represented taxpayers before the IRS for more than 33 years. If you’d like to talk through your situation, the first consultation is free.